We had Lis’s old boss over for a Fudge-Off: she vacations on Block Island and brought fudge from Blocks of Fudge; we of course provided fudge from Murdick’s on the Vineyard. This is penuche and plain chocolate from each.
The verdict: the smoothness and chocolate flavor from Blocks of Fudge works better, but the granular texture and butter flavor of Murdick’s penuche is superior and won the day.